Nokia’s IPcom patent problem

Posted on Updated on

If it wasn’t bad enough that Nokia backed the three legged horse in the smartphone race (Windows Phone 7), its now got another problem on its hands.

It is reported by the Wall Street Journal that a court has ruled Nokia is infringing a patent belonging to IPCom:

The ruling means IPCom could seek an injunction to force Nokia to halt sales of its third-generation mobile phones in Germany unless Nokia pays a license fee for the patent.

Source: Wall Street Journal

Can things get any worse?

Elop’s “burning platform” seems to still be burning…. How long before it burns out?

Tim (Goblin)

If you are new to this blog (or have not yet read it) please take time to view the OpenBytes statement, here.

Skype: tim.openbytes

Nokia & Microsoft sign deal ahead of schedule – Time is of the essence?

Posted on

I’ve spoken previously about the Nokia/Microsoft deal and I believe its been covered once or twice on the TechBytes show too.

Hot of the Microsoft press (albeit its news center) Microsoft is announcing that it has signed the deal with Nokia which was reported in February, earlier than expected.

Nokia (NYSE: NOK) and Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT) today announced the signing of a definitive agreement on a partnership that will result in a new global mobile ecosystem, utilizing the very complementary assets of both companies. 


Amongst the bold claims and patting each other on the back, here’s one part of the release which I found interesting:

Microsoft will receive a running royalty from Nokia for the Windows Phone platform, starting when the first Nokia products incorporating Windows Phone ship. The royalty payments are competitive and reflect the large volumes that Nokia expects to ship…..


“….large volumes Nokia expects to ship”? and where’s that expectation from? What evidence is there to suggest WP7 is going to be at best anything other than a very small piece of an Apple/Android pie?  Maybe I missed the queues outside stores when WP7 launched? Maybe I’ve missed the lacking features installed and maybe I imagined the reports of data gobbling and upgrade crashes on the net? – All the while Android phones and Apple are getting out products by the bucketload.  I must have missed some major WP7 successes for Nokia/Microsoft expecting to ship large volumes. ;)

Or maybe Microsoft has a different definition of the word “large”?  I suppose if you use Kin sales as a measuring stick then “large” is not very many at all.

Then of course when you get to the end of the article I see the section on “Forward looking statements” which suggests to me the justification for the “large volumes” comment and appears in my view, as a disclaimer to everything said before it.  You decide though, its all on the links provided.

To me, this early signing shows that its crunch time.  Microsoft in my view has realized its now or never and it’s got to be quick.  Do I think this will make any difference to the acceptance of WP7? – No.   Do I think the WP7 will be Ballmers final stand? – Yes.  Do I think that everything concerning the WP7 is too little too late? – Yes.  

Sorry if my opinion upsets any MVP’s or Microsoft advocates, but as we saw in a previous post, it appears even some of the long time faithful are feeling a little downhearted. 

Time will tell.


If you are new to this blog (or have not yet read it) please take time to view the OpenBytes statement, here.

Skype: tim.openbytes
I can also be found in #techrights, #techbytes on