CLOSING REPORT – CASE #01 – ANDRE DA COSTA

The laptop Andre admits to recieving is believed to be similar to this.  A nice gift for someone in Jamaica. since its worth around twice what the average worker make in a year.
The laptop Andre is alleged to have recieved is similar to this. A nice gift for someone in Jamaica. since its worth around twice what the average worker make in a year.

Firstly the purpose of this report is not to draw any inference over how much impartiality a person who receives a gift from a company has.  This is more to do with informing readering, so that they can have the full facts at their disposal when reading someones opinion on that particular companies products.

Computer magazines are quite clear that they recieve review copies, and I think people keep that in mind when reading their articles.  The same should be true of bloggers and reporters on the net.  Since the net now is one of the main ways we get our information and opinion, I believe its important that full disclosure on any gifts is clear.

Andre Da Costa first came to my attention in my first few weeks of Microsoft Watch posting.  I noticed almost imediately that his posts lacked “personality” and to me looked like a copy & paste from a PR sheet.  We had “Vista is loved” and “feature rich” et al, which to me didnt sound like a user with an honest held belief in the “greatness” of any product.

So he was challenged.  Questions regarding his “Microsoft facts” were mostly met with more PR or ignored.

Moving on about 4 months, it was the user “Chips” who enlightened me that Andre had recieved a free laptop, believed to be similar to the one in the photo.  He also provided a link to Andre’s own site where it was proudly displayed (along with a photograph of, I believe him) waving at the camera all smiles.

This is where the story, in my opinion gets a little sad.  The average salary for someone who lives (as Andres claims) in Jamaica is around $3790 per year, which makes the approx $6000 laptop gift/review model etc a very BIG and GENEROUS gift.   One could be forgiven for going down this line of thinking:

A lad in a country which has known economic problems, is sent a laptop which the worth two years of salary for an average person.  One could be forgiven for thinking that the lad would obviously go off and promote the company that sent it, firstly out of gratitude and secondly in the hope more free gifts would be forthcoming.  For a company this could be considered as money well spent. Like I say, I hope Im forgiven for thinking that.

Andres comment on Twitter

So when the matter was put to Andre, he was reluctant to give a proper answer.   It took another user (Ridley) to make the admittion for him, although how Ridley was in a position to speak for Andre and why Ridley took it upon himself to do so (well I will let you make your own mind up there, however there were allegations of the word “sock puppet”

So now it appears in 2007 Andre Da Costa did infact receive a gift/review laptop from Microsoft.  Boycott Novell has also written an article on this and that can be accessed here.

If you would like to see previous posts from this site in regards to the case, please click the links below.

https://openbytes.wordpress.com/2009/01/26/open-letter-to-andre-da-costa/

https://openbytes.wordpress.com/2009/01/27/do-as-i-say-not-as-i-do-andre-da-costa-and-friends/

https://openbytes.wordpress.com/2009/01/29/andre-da-costa-update-pt1/

On a final note, this is to you Andre.  Whilst you have claimed Im a stalker which I take great exception to and at the same time thrown other personal insults at me, I would just like to let you know I forgive you.  I believe I now understand why you post as you do in regards to Windows and Microsoft.

Maybe as a gesture which would do well in my opinion, for both yourself and Microsoft is to put the laptop up on auction on Ebay and donate the money to the upcoming Comic Relief fund raiser.  I think this would go a long way to show, as you suggest, you are impartial and not in the least bias.

cartoon-cd-character-clip-art-thumb2776131

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 05/02/2009

The one thing the Openbytes is happy to do is give people a right of reply.  Now since Andre has not emailed with a full account (which is a shame as I would have printed it)  It seems that the user Ridley has an allegation about a comment Andre Da Costa made.

Now whilst I was/am of the opinion that it was infact Ridley who was trying to claim Linux needed a compiler just to run a music CD (since he posted that and made no attempt to challenge it or claim it was Andre Da Costa at the time) I will take him on his word and post the comment that Ridley alleges Andre Da Costa says (and you can see the entire thread in its context in the link below it):

“Linux, you are just suffering, trying to find a compiler to play a music CD. Can’t watch something as basic as a DVD movie. Windows is about letting the user do positive things, thats why over a billion users are taking advantage of it, thats why Windows has dominated the Netbook market with 80% marketshare. Linux just does not get it, we are not close minded to the OS, but Linux is not Windows and does not share the positive qualities that Windows delivers through value rich solutions and services.”

http://www.microsoft-watch.com/content/windows_7/windows_7_model_for_microsoft_reinvention.html

Maybe that is another thing users can keep in mind when reading articles and “good reviews” by Andre Da Costa.

As always Andre has a right of reply, and should I receive one, I will print it here.  Andre has been absent from Microsoft Watch, but when he returns I will put the allegation to him and print his reply here.

8 Comments Add yours

  1. Will says:

    Not sure why, but the Boycott Novell article link appears to be broken. When I clicked there, I got this:

    url: http://boycottnovell.com/2009/02/01/andre-da-costa-schwag/

    content:

    Not Found

    Sorry, but the page you requested cannot be found.

    ———

    You might want to get that cleared up with Boycott Novell, fix it to the correct link, or take it down, just for the sake of accuracy.

  2. Will says:

    On second look, it might be a temporary problem on Boycott Novell’s end after all:

    http://boycottnovell.com/2009/02/01/status-report-recovery-ongoing/

    Maybe it will clear up soon.
    Anyway, cheers, “RN” (lol!)

  3. openbytes says:

    Yeah Ive spoken to Roy. It appears to be a hosting problem that is to be resolved soon.

    Its hoped to be sorted shortly.

    Goblin

  4. openbytes says:

    In regards to RN, as I say its one of the dead ends Ive created.

    I can tell how much investigation the shillers are doing by which name they print. Some are easy (RN) and some are very hard to find. It will be funny watching which one comes up next.

  5. Feklar says:

    Andre game is over.Hes never been taken seriously anyway and now he will just be looked at as a paid for opinion.
    great feature!

  6. openbytes says:

    The article on Andre is now back up at Boycott Novell.

  7. Minty says:

    nice article…thanks

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s